What’s more polarizing than a good ‘ole Calvinism/Arminianism standoff?! Today, Mark and Justin take on this vast subject that pits the seemingly opposing views of God’s sovereignty versus man’s free will. Is there room for both? Can we have our cake and eat it too? Maybe we don’t answer all the questions, but we certainly share a bit more about how we see it.

Show Notes:

Show Transcript

Justin:

Here’s my question. Alright, so we’re gonna we’re gonna move into a uh an illustration or uh or metaphor You think about a chess player.

Mark:

Sure. Right. So many moves ahead.

Justin:

Right. Don’t get ahead of me, Mark.

Mark:

Sorry. Yes. I apologize. Welcome to How I See It with me, Mark Pratt and Justin Sternberg. This is a podcast that works to counter cultural polarization through thoughtful conversations.

Getting in my position

Justin:

Locked in.

Mark:

Ready to go.

Justin:

Alright. So here’s here’s my thought.

Mark:

Yeah? Oh, we’re not just doing off the cuff. You’re prefacing me. You’re pref

Justin:

I mean this is off the cuff. Off the cuff preface seeing it.

Mark:

Okay, cool.

Justin:

Um one very polarizing topic in like Christianity is this idea of God ‘s sovereignty, once saved, always saved, predestination. You ready to go go deep this morning?

Mark:

I can do that. I can do that Sure. Are we gonna yeah

Justin:

go ahead? Cool, cool.

Mark:

No, I was I was thinking from a scriptural context. Are we bringing any?

Justin:

Alright, so I’ll probably quote.

Mark:

Okay.

Justin:

Or, you know, just

Mark:

paraphrase.

Justin:

Paraphrase you there.

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

It’s gonna be how I see it. It’s gonna how I see it episode. Of how do you see it, Mark? Because The Bible very clearly uses language about free will.

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

And our ability to make choices. And very clearly tells us to make choices, right?

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

Um, while at the same time it very clearly talks about God’s sovereignty and that he’s in control, he’s in in charge. And if you read Romans 9, I mean basically Paul is saying Some things are made for destruction and some are made for glory. And you know, he uses the metaphor of um Like uh a waste basket. Some things are made to be a waste basket or something like that.

Mark:

Sure, sure.

Justin:

He’s talking about the potter and how you know y

Mark:

some vessels

Justin:

Right. Basically

Mark:

are for destructive purposes and others are made for destruction, yes.

Justin:

Yes.

Mark:

And even when I think about that, I think about, you know, it’s um uh here again the brothers you know that he actually liked one brother he actu you know in an old testament dynamic Like

Justin:

Esau or Jacob I love, Esau I hated, or that whole

Mark:

thing That perspective as far as it it seeming as if he had a favorite or he did You know, with with a purpose in mind.

Justin:

Yep.

Mark:

Yeah. So I’m I’m hearing where you’re coming from. That’s what’s coming to my mind. It’s like, how can a loving God Kind of choose one over the other.

Justin:

Right. So my I kinda want to just play with some ideas in terms of like why, how, etcetera.

Mark:

Hmm.

Justin:

Um, and kinda get your thoughts.

Mark:

Oh, okay.

Justin:

Yeah?

Mark:

Yeah, I’m good. I’m yeah.

Justin:

So one struggle that I get that I hear a lot from from people and and myself as well is this idea that well everyone not everyone most people believe that God is omniscient.

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

Right? And so omniscient

Mark:

omniscience

Justin:

is knowing everything.

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

Right? Right?

Mark:

Right.

Justin:

And another uh what do we call these definitions? No uh attributes. Attribute. Another attribute of God that most people agree with without without any kind of argument or whatever is his omnipotence.

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

Right? Which is

Mark:

power.

Justin:

His all powerfulness.

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

Right? So if he knows everything and he has ultimate power, right?

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

Um

Mark:

and yet in our language we can create these paradigms that say is he big enough to be able to do this? You know ,

Justin:

he’s big enough to make a rock he can’t pick up. Pick up, sure. Yeah, yeah.

Mark:

All that stuff that kinda from our human understanding we wrestle with

Justin:

Yeah.

Mark:

Yes.

Justin:

Yeah. And that’s that’s that’s what that’s what I want to do. Wrestle a little bit.

Mark:

I’m all for it.

Justin:

Um So here’s here’s where we get stuck, right?

Mark:

We?

Justin:

I’m not sure I’m stuck yet.

Mark:

We oh as people.

Justin:

We as people who get stuck.

Mark:

Sure. Sure.

Justin:

Um You think about this fact that he’s omniscient. He knows everything.

Mark:

Mm-hmm.

Justin:

Um, does he know everything in the future, all possible opportunities? What do you think?

Mark:

I believe so.

Justin:

I believe so as well. Here’s my question. Alright, so we’re gonna move into a uh an illustration or metaphor. You think about a chess player.

Mark:

Sure. Right. So many moves ahead.

Justin:

Right.

Mark:

Don’t get ahead of me, Mark. Sorry. Yes. I apologize.

Justin:

No, okay, so it’s a genius chess player, best chess player in the world, and the reason they’re so good is because they know every possible move at any given point. Right? Sure. So Key difference. Key or a key a key important detail here.

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

They don’t know your mind.

Mark:

Correct.

Justin:

Okay? But they know every other variable in terms of that chessboard. So The minute the game starts, you move your piece, and this person says, okay, I just calculated every single possible ult, you know path that this thing could take, which is impossible. I mean billions and billions of

Mark:

options.

Justin:

option like just it’s ridiculous right but they can do it right so they churn through like computer or whatever and they go okay based on what he just did I’m gonna do this now because I just did this All of those things shifted, right? All those op potential future options that you might take and uh that I might take, etc. etc. All of them shift. But now I’ve made a decision, right? Sure. And now you react to that, right?

Mark:

Yep.

Justin:

And you may do exactly what I thought you were going to do, or you might do something that’s like, wait, oh, I see. did that and now calculate all the possible right

Mark:

calculating right recalculating

Justin:

exactly and the game goes on and on and he crushes you right because he’s knows all the possible moves. Sure. You’re just living in this world, right?

Mark:

I gotcha.

Justin:

It’s no offense to you, Mark. I don’t know how good you are at chest. But this person is basically a a computer.

Mark:

This is our analogy.

Justin:

Yes.

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

So obviously that’s very powerful. Would you say they are all powerful?

Mark:

Hmm. That’s where I would have to. I would wrestle with it from a human. computerized dynamic of what we know. And I think that’s for me I think some of what we wrestle with in that context, what I I respect the question, but it’s like I want to follow the the vein, but I also recognize that we don’t always understand. So yes Uh re ask ask me the question one more time. I want to clarify.

Justin:

Yeah, so the question is, if this person knows all possible moves you might make and therefore can Create a plan based on that. Would you consider them all powerful? Omnipotent? In the game of specifically. I would have to say

Mark:

specifically in the game of chess. Yes, if that was possible, I would consider that omniscience of knowing. The ability to know.

Justin:

Omniscient. What about omnipotent?

Mark:

And there again, uh, it’s it would be for me to define what power is. And I don’t necessarily, I when I think of chess, I think of it as a mental uh the ability to know a person’s thoughts. You follow me? I wouldn’t necessarily consider that all powerful. I would consider that all knowing. And that would be how that would be why I would decipher, I would say, yeah, I would consider that person omniscient, the ability to know, but I just it’s it’s a I’m just thinking about it from that aspect of power because I don’t necessarily see power equated with chess.

Justin:

Right. Right, that’s fine. You

Mark:

you follow me? I see power as as creation. To be able to have the power the ability to speak. uh something into existence. Not that we don’t have a certain ability, you know, our our words are tremendously power. They’re, you know, they’re nuclear, but yet. I can’t necessarily make a solar system just by my words. But that’s how I would equate, you know, that would that would be something that I would attribute to omnipotence.

Justin:

Yeah.

Mark:

Does that make sense? I’m not trying to, I’m not trying to, you know, it’s part of the wrestling. So yeah, that would be how I would see it. I would say that person is omniscient To be able to know.

Justin:

That that all works.

Mark:

Okay.

Justin:

If if if I’m okay to keep going.

Mark:

You’re okay, yeah. You’re okay as far as I’m concerned.

Justin:

So Let’s up the ante.

Mark:

Okay, sure.

Justin:

Not only can this person know every possible move, right? And all the calculations to know if this person does this all the way through, right?

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

To the game being every single possible.

Mark:

Predict every move that I would make.

Justin:

No, not predict

Mark:

Oh no. React

Justin:

to every move you make and have the whole game completed, no matter which path you take. Follow every single possible path.

Mark:

I wouldn’t see that as omniscient. if a person is reacting. I would see that as something less because I would believe that person would need to know.

Justin:

Right. Right.

Mark:

You follow me?

Justin:

So here ‘s what I’m gonna up the ante.

Mark:

Okay. And I hear where you’re coming from. I’m seeing what yeah, you’re good. Roll with it.

Justin:

Not only do they know all the things to do based on what you will do, they know what you will do. Not what you might do, what you will do.

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

Right? Once they have that piece of knowledge, what you will do, along with all the possible.

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

But they know the one

Mark:

that I will choose to do. Yes, exactly.

Justin:

Are they not now c in complete control of the game?

Mark:

Well

Justin:

How can they not be?

Mark:

Because and here ‘s where I’m coming from That person would still have the ability to make the choice. So I wouldn’t say they were in control Because each person has that choice and the what are we calling him a professional? What are we calling this person then?

Justin:

Guru.

Mark:

The guru. The chess guru knows that knows it, but it doesn’t necessarily take away the player’s option to choose. My option, sorry. Sorry. The guru knows it, but it doesn’t take away my option to choose each and every time. And if I want to start my first move with my knight or a pawn, it makes no difference. I still have that choice.

Justin:

Yeah. I I’m not disagreeing.

Mark:

Yeah, yeah, I’m not they’re not uh that’s that’s just me making it.

Justin:

Yes what I’m saying is

Mark:

What are you saying?

Justin:

Is your choice in a illusion.

Mark:

Hmm.

Justin:

Because

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

Again, if I know every possible move and I like I’ve already determined I’m gonna win the game, okay?

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

And so I know

Mark:

that’s a good illustration too.

Justin:

Yeah.

Mark:

The guru wins the game. Yes. The guru

Justin:

wins.

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

And not only does he win, he wins with the castle being here and the bishop being here and your king being here. Like there are some predefin predefined parameters that we know the game will end in. Because they’re it’s written down.

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

Right? In order to accomplish that, those things, based on what you’re I know you’re going to do, Hang on, I’m still I’m I’m calculating.

Mark:

Yeah, I see it. I see it. Well I’m good with it. I’m good with it.

Justin:

For me, it’s just hard to distinguish from From being all-knowing, past, future, present, and all powerful, but yet not Free will being a a an illusion.

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

Which I’m okay with. Just just so we’re clear.

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

I I that I’m not upset by that.

Mark:

No.

Justin:

But that’s like That that’s what that’s my question. That’s my wrestling. That’s the

Mark:

That’s the conundrum for you in that context. Because it seems as if If he knows, it it somehow diminishes your ability to choose. What is the conundrum then? Help me understand that.

Justin:

Um for me it’s not a conundrum. I just believe it’s a illusion that I’m happy to live by and I’m commanded to commanded to live by this illusion.

Mark:

So it’s not that there is a And

Justin:

for all intents and purposes in my life, I meant to walk in that understanding that I have. this free will.

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

But I have this even better knowledge that says, yeah, but I know the truth, which is you’re in control. And quote unquote, I can’t mess up. That being said, I know what it feels like when I’m walking away from him and I don’t want that. Like, I have my free will to do what he promises in his word will you know, my life will be blessed and I will have a a better relationship with him and all these things are better as a result of my choices.

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

But it’s also like I have this comfort. Or this trust, this belief that Mark, you’re not gonna mess it up. You’re not gonna mess up God’s plan. I’m not worried about you living in your world messing up his plans.

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

Now Let’s go all the way to the top. I’m not worried about the president messing up his plans. I’m not worried about the world order that controls everything that people talk about messing up his plans. Because I know he knows what they’re thinking, what they’re going to do. You know what I mean?

Mark:

Yeah. And

Justin:

whether, you know, you get down the the semantics of whether he’s Like whether that’s an illusion or not. It really doesn’t matter at that point. But um I don’t know What do you think?

Mark:

And and that’s what and I guess I guess what comes to mind for me is I think about it from as I interact with people. Uh some people will say, you know, some people have a hard time saying we are blessed to be here. here in America because it sounds as if we are somehow enlightened or higher. They they they don’t like that they They see it as a luck. They want to refer to it as I’m lucky to be here. Because in their mind, they’re wrestling with that dynamic that says, okay, why am I here and someone else is someplace else.

Justin:

Yeah.

Mark:

You know, and they wrestle with that because from from what I understand their perspective to be It seems as if I’ve been put in a better spot and that other person has been put in a lesser spot.

Justin:

Yeah.

Mark:

And how could that happen from a loving God type thing? And I and so for me, I don’t, I don’t, I, I wrestle with that thinking on their part because it’s like I can recognize there is a plan. There is a choice and it doesn’t mean that one is better or worse because I I believe they have their differences You follow me? I I I I think there’s I think there’s definite advantages to being here, but I also think, you know, in America type dynamic, but I also think there’s so many more distractions. That can kind of and you know, I see, you know, commercialism and you know and the ability to have wealth as being a blessing, but I can also see how in that free will we can choose and many things we can put in place of God.

Justin:

Yeah, and uh

Mark:

substitutions. Sorry, go ahead.

Justin:

No You go ahead.

Mark:

Yeah, you were saying I.

Justin:

Uh I I feel very strongly that the uptick and depression, anxiety, all these things. directly correlates with the uh level of comfort we have. So yes, we’re so blessed. But the fact that we don’t have to dwell every single day on how am I gonna get food in my children’s mouths leaves me with more existential problems to solve.

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

You know what I mean?

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

And so we are blessed. But I would be uh ignorant to say I am more blessed than the the village in Africa that you know A missionary just brought Jesus to and they have this incredible joy and every day they work their freaking butts off to provide for their family and and and not die, right? Like to not And yet they have a bigger smile, a bitter a bigger existential joy than uh than I could ever know in my life. Because I don’t know the pain they’ve known. You know what I’m saying?

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

And so I know that’s uh we’re definitely in a sidebar at this point, but that that I think when we talk about being blessed, blessings are um personal

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

Right. And so there are people who live in this blessed country who are cursed. They’re just miserable. They cannot find joy and they have yachts.

Mark:

Valid point. And that that’s what makes it similar for me. Is and not even necessarily a sidebar, because it is that ability that we have to choose a free will. And and God can still use that, you know, and I can choose to take wherever I am. And granted, that my my if I grow up in a different place, my view of God would likely be very different than if I grew up in the United States of America.

Justin:

Absolutely. You

Mark:

follow me?

Justin:

Yeah.

Mark:

And so with that being said, from my perspective, I I’m probably in a I’m gonna be, from what I understand, in agreement with you. in that process that all of it is part of that greater plan. So it’s not about one being better, one being worse, there is a plan that says there’s a purpose in it all. And our minds aren’t able to always recognize it. Even even like right now in this, you know, it’s like I don’t recognize the purpose in my father-in-law’s circumstance. And, you know, where Chris and I are at, and you know, living s you know, living separately. We’re not separated, of course, you know, and we’re still by God’s grace connected, but it’s like that becomes the wrestling. It’s like, okay, God, what’s the purpose in that? And I and I think so often in the midst of a circumstance, it’s easy to question it’s It’s it’s human nature, I would say, to question because we’re caught in that middle ground. And I think, you know, that’s that’s where Or anytime when we’re when we’re stuck, whether we’re thinking we’re stuck, whether we’re feeling we’re stuck. You know, in a situation, I think that’s the difficult part because we recognize there is a choice. And in that moment, that choice is very real.

Justin:

Yeah.

Mark:

And it’s and it’s and it’s you know at times palatable. We can just you know it’s like which way do I go? Because she’s there and she’s doing exactly what she needs to be doing, and yet I’m here and we feel this distance and a uh you know I’m not saying I feel it more or less than she does, but yet, you know, I are we’re just on such different ends.

Justin:

Yeah.

Mark:

that it becomes difficult to understand where each other are at. But ultimately, this is this is for me the grace in it, is being able to recognize there’s a purpose and a plan.

Justin:

Mm-hmm.

Mark:

And whether I’m whether I make wise moves that basically say I d I check my own emotions and I don’t blame and I don’t, you know, get angry at people for no reason. I don’t be well, I sometimes I do become a little little grumpy.

Justin:

But

Mark:

what’s that?

Justin:

I’m sorry. No, no.

Mark:

But yeah, I think that’s the in that in that moment Is is is where I’m at to be able to recognize and step back from it all and say, okay, God, what is the purpose in this? Because I’m not better, no one’s worse, that kind of thing. But yet your love for all people Is able to know the moves they’re gonna make, and the guru is actually still reflecting his love for us by the plan. And ultimately whoever makes the choice, whoever makes the decision from the governmental level to the local level to the personal level, you know, it’s What I experience, what other people around the world experience is still part of that love, even if we’re not able to see it based on the current circumstance.

Justin:

Yeah. I think of um I mean I think of uh The Hiding Place with Cory Tinboom. She wrote a book and she lived through the Nazi Holocaust and you know, went through terrible situations there. Yeah. Um like just reading her book, there was I mean, obviously times. that she said, I cannot fathom God having purpose in this terrible place in this terrible situation. situation. I just and yet her sister a lot of the book is her just talking about how beautiful her sister’s faith was and saying, I’m just barely hanging on to the coattails of my sister. sister’s faith at some point. And yet we know her as a giant of faith. Yeah. She’s the one who after getting out and the war ending, she ended up traveling the rest of her life and speaking. And I mean for us now in her in her books, there’s no doubt to that purpose.

Mark:

Yeah. You know.

Justin:

Hindsight, yeah.

Mark:

Yes.

Justin:

And She would never choose that path.

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

I would never choose that path. Or are you thinking about like I said, the p the people in Africa who if they could choose to have born in a m be be born in America, mm-hmm they would of course choose that.

Mark:

Mm

Justin:

right? I would rather have that pain of depression than the pain of these blisters on my hand and whatever, right? Like it just gets really I don’t know, we’ll say interesting.

Mark:

No

Justin:

doubt.

Mark:

And it and it and it I and here again, I think so much of that comes from our ability and in that moment in the moment where the and and here again I don’t I don’t want to simplify this I wanna I want to recognize there’s a depth to every person’s experience. You follow me? To where and and it so because I don’t Yeah, my concern is that I come across as arrogant and and not having empathy.

Justin:

Me too.

Mark:

So that I wanna I wanna recognize that That’s not where I’m at. I want to recognize that no matter where an individual is in the midst of a trial, of a of a difficult circumstance you know that moment um there’s a it there’s a terminology um that will there’s a it’s actually a theory gestalt You know, and yes, and and basically it is it is those things that are in the forefront of my mind. It’s like you put your hand in front of your face. you know, and it’s very difficult to see you if you know or the mic or anything like that because it’s it’s about you know um The sum total is greater than the whole type thing, but we have these things that come into our view and it’s difficult to see the force through the trees.

Justin:

Yeah, yeah.

Mark:

Okay, once the tree is in front of us, it’s hard to see the rest of the forest. That’s that’s kind of what that means. And I think when we’re in those trials It’s hard to s look back at times and say, okay, this is where God was faithful in this situation. This is where God was faithful in this situation. Situation, and he’s still just as faithful now with this tree right in front of me as he will be tomorrow’s trees, that kind of thing. And I and I think As humans, that becomes the difficult part is to be able to recognize the the journey, or if you will, the video versus the snapshot Because so often I hold up, I’m I’m in the midst of the snapshot. I’m living out this moment. And sometimes it’s difficult to recognize that there’s a purpose and it and there’s an entire video and at the end of the video

Justin:

you know

Mark:

the guru wins and that guru winning is to everyone’s benefit

Justin:

Yeah, another illustration of that that I’ve thought of many times in my own life in terms of Exactly what you’re saying is is art, this giant canvas on the wall, and it’s all about how d how much you’re zoomed in, right? Right. Sure. There’s nothing to see for for as far as you can see, it’s black.

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

It’s dark. There’s there’s nothing but dark. It’s just dark. It’s a dark painting. It’s a dark art. It’s just the artist is dark, right? And yet if you zoom out far enough and are able to see the whole canvas, uh, that could be a shadow of a beautiful tree, right? Or it could be what you know, the nose of a beaver. Right? Like depending on how far you zoom out, it could be a speck

Mark:

Right.

Justin:

Um, or how far you were zoom zoomed in in the first place. And I think that’s that big huge canvas that represents Past, present, future.

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

The past beyond what we know.

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

And the future beyond what we know. You know, as far as it stretches, we don’t know how big that canvas is

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

Because we didn’t create it. We c we can’t see it. We’re we’ll never be well, I don’t know, never. Hopefully someday we’ll be able to travel it. I don’t know. And

Mark:

and here again, it’s interesting as I think about it in our c in a in a how I see it You know, I think at times you you mentioned the beaver’s nose and everything’s dark. I also want to recognize that some people are in a spot or might be in a moment where they see yellow.

Justin:

Yeah.

Mark:

And everything’s bright. And everything’s and yet that can change as I move along the tapestry.

Justin:

Yes.

Mark:

You know, and and I think that’s important for us us to understand. It’s like This is where I’m at today is momentary.

Justin:

And that’s why we talk so much about how I see it, right? Because it’s this idea that Conversations are so important and t for me to say no, you’re seeing it wrong. It’s all yellow. You just need to believe better. That it’s yellow or open your eyes and see that it’s yellow and let me just explain to you why it’s yellow and yellow, yellow, yellow yellow yellow, and you’re like, um No, right. You’re wrong.

Mark:

And I think

Justin:

so wrong.

Mark:

Sure. And I think we can do that with people who are in their dark spot.

Justin:

Right That’s what I’m saying. Yeah. You can be like, just believe better and just have more faith and just

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

It’s not dark. You’re you just have to change your mindset. That’s right. Positive mental attitude.

Mark:

You’ll be in a yellow you’re in a yellow spot and you just don’t see it.

Justin:

Yeah. You just gotta buck up, you know. Yes. Yeah. But it’s like, no, the reality is you are in a dark spot.

Mark:

Yes. And

Justin:

no amount of yellow talk is gonna fix that

Mark:

that’s correct I’d agree with that and it and I and I think w if we want to go to the free will dynamic it’s easy to say that person chose that If we’re gonna really wrestle with the you follow me, that person’s there because they did this, this, and this. And if they didn’t do that, they’d be in a yellow spot just like me.

Justin:

Right. Yes.

Mark:

And so therein there I think coming back to the point it go it go it does go to that aspect of okay. the purpose versus the free will. And can I make uh healthy choices and still experience darkness in my life?

Justin:

Right. Right. Can you?

Mark:

Yes.

Justin:

Yes.

Mark:

Yes. Yes. No doubt. Can

Justin:

happen.

Mark:

Yes. So the reason why. Go ahead.

Justin:

You were gonna say something.

Mark:

Yeah, it was because I I I don’t think we’re given I don’t think it’s God’s design to live in a utopian system. So someday, but right now there’s a purpose. And and today is and even in that uh in what you refer to as the someday utopian, you know, there’s still gonna be there’s still gonna be work from my perspective.

Justin:

Yeah.

Mark:

Because there’s a purpose in it. And I think, you know, um this ability to wrestle and you know when I think of uh you know just God’s interaction with people, you know, and and putting them in spots where they have to wrestle with him. I think that’s a part of the dynamic and the purpose that says, okay, yeah, trust

Justin:

me.

Mark:

And yet you’re not going to understand it all.

Justin:

Right.

Mark:

You’re my mind, I’m not saying your mind, but my mind isn’t able to always comprehend Because otherwise, if we could comprehend it all, we’d be omniscient.

Justin:

Right.

Mark:

But instead, we’re created in his image with certain abilities. And we’re, you know, and even and as as we’ve shared before, there’s so much of God reflected in male and female. That, you know, we just no one person has it all. No one person can understand it all. And that’s that’s the beauty of uh what we’re offered from my perspective. And I and I think so often it is in those momentary hurts That I lash out and I start to say, okay, this God isn’t loving. This God doesn’t care about me. You know, and if he’s so whatever, fill in the blank, you wouldn’t have this and this and this and this.

Justin:

Right.

Mark:

And I think that’s where that’s where we run into the conflict.

Justin:

I think that’s where the the breakdown happens to where you say, Well that’s why I don’t believe that.

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

That’s why I believe in free will and I believe you know, uh Arminianism like that whole idea of like Calvinism versus Arminianism. This idea that no, it’s up to me. It’s up to my you know, it’s it’s free will a hundred percent all the way at you know all the way up and down. And Um, because I cannot grasp that. I cannot allow that to be true and I think when you venture towards the other direction you say, it has to be true, so where am I wrong in how I think about it? What am how am I viewing God that doesn’t allow this to be true?

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

And ha and how is that wrong? How can how can all the things I believe about him to be true still be true and that also be true?

Mark:

that

Justin:

bad things can happen. He can allow it. He can predestine it.

Mark:

Use it.

Justin:

Use it.

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

Exactly.

Mark:

And and that and that’s where I I’m a I’m a Calvarminian. Calvarminian.

Justin:

Calvarminian.

Mark:

You know, to the point of recognizing, yes, it’s all of because of who we get stuck.

Justin:

I don’t have to tell Megan there’s a name for what she is.

Mark:

Calvar minion. Because I think that’s that’s the beauty of it.

Justin:

Yeah.

Mark:

That r that continuum is the is the abil is I see that as being like black and white. Well, it’s gotta be black or it’s gotta be white. And we can recognize that no, you know, if we’re going to those far extremes, yes. That’s I mean, but That doesn’t mean white doesn’t exist even if I’m all the way on the black side. And even if I’m on the white side, I’m not assigning that, but you know what I’m saying. It it doesn’t mean that black doesn’t exist And I think that’s where we get stuck is when we think because I’m here, you know, in light gray, then then black doesn’t exist. And if you’re if you’re of the the black thinking, the dark side thinking, then something’s wrong with you.

Justin:

Mm-hmm. Yeah.

Mark:

Because you just don’t understand. And I and I think that’s that’s the beauty of scripture from my perspective, is it’s all true.

Justin:

Yes.

Mark:

It’s big God’s big enough for it to all be true and that’s okay.

Justin:

Yeah.

Mark:

For us.

Justin:

Yeah. I agree.

Mark:

It’s not that, you know, he’s some angry person that is, you know, has his you know, God-sized fly swatter looking to swap you because you did this. And therefore, you know, you’re you’re going through, and I’m not making light of anyone’s situation, but you know. that you’re going through this current sickness or this, you know, physical or mental, you know, sickness and that’s somehow God punishing you.

Justin:

Mm

Mark:

for choices you’ve made and you know, that kind of thing. And I I mean I’d still recognize that yes, the choices we make would be reaping and sowing consequences. I I believe there are consequences, but just because I’m experiencing doesn’t always mean that I’ve chosen poorly.

Justin:

Yes. Or sometimes it doesn’t when you receive the consequences for choosing poorly uh those consequences even in har harsh I’m not talking about like like I got off with less than I deserved. I’m talking about you’re dealing with the real results, the real consequences. Even those can serve as light points.

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

As moments where we recognize a loving God who’s who will not be mocked and who is saying, I love you, but you will experience this. You will learn the the consequence for that action. And there’s a huge difference between condemnation there and saying like, well, I deserve this and da-da-da-da. And I must, you know, I have to walk through this and God’s mad at me and I have to pay my you know, penance or whatever. And recognizing that as a loving father who just spanked me and he’s gonna hold me after. after and he’s gonna walk next to me well you know while I cry, you know.

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

While I experience the pain of the consequence.

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

And he’s not sitting up there judging me and angry. He’s saying, I did tell you, you know, I did warn you. And uh I sent this person and I sent this thing and this circumstance, you know.

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

And uh I the reason I’m so, you know, very passionate about this particular part of the topic. I mean the whole topic really.

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

But I I grew up in a church that was very Armenian, very free will, very Um, it all hinged on my actions.

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

And so my blessings depended on my actions. My curses depended on my actions. My flat tire depended on on, you know, my actions and, you know, I’ve talked about this before, but struggled with pornography when I was young. And so every time something bad happened in my life, I could always tie it back to the last time I slipped.

Mark:

Hmm.

Justin:

And I always did. I just said, Well, this makes sense. Black tire, I it’s because I have that. And I deserve this and I guess We’ll just have to deal with this and you know, maybe ba after I get through this consequence, uh I can be close to God again until I choose poorly again and then I’ll have to do this again.

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

It was this ongoing battle of trying to stay holy but not being able to do it because my free will is broken and I

Mark:

like

Justin:

the flesh, you know? And my theology shifted um you know I want to say early college into high school as I learned about this other side of God.

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

This sovereignty. As I saw the white paint And I’d only seen black my whole life. Or whatever color you call it. I don’t uh it’s not about wrong, right, or whatever, it’s about nuance.

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

And learning that, oh God is loving in this as well.

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

And he’s sovereign. So somehow, like there’s this this wrestling, this somehow wrestling that I think no matter what illustrations we come up with

Mark:

No I hear you.

Justin:

There will always be wrestling. I I’m okay with that. I enjoy that. That’s what this conversation is about.

Mark:

And and the thing I like about what you’re sharing and it kind of comes to my mind is the aspect of I think sometimes we think learning is instantaneous. You follow me? It’s like I need to memorize this. I need to, you know, and I’m I’m I wanna be able to learn. I wanna be able to I almost I just wanna be able to move through it.

Justin:

Right.

Mark:

And some of the learning that you’re describing, you know, in that process of moving from one extreme to you know, a more general life.

Justin:

I would say I went to the other extreme.

Mark:

Would you?

Justin:

And I would say that learning that you’re talking about is a lifetime. learning.

Mark:

Yes. And I

Justin:

‘ve come away from the other extreme to now I’m I just it’s somehow in the middle. I’ve definitely leaned more Calvinism and more

Mark:

but yeah

Justin:

I at the same time I recognize free will and I accept that and I you know it’s like this

Mark:

and so in that in let’s let’s go there then do you in your viewpoint have the ability to influence God? Or influence the guru, if you will, from your analogy?

Justin:

I believe what the Bible says, which is that he invites us into a relationship with him as a child. And so, as much as I believe, I think that yes, absolutely.

Mark:

Gotcha.

Justin:

But I also think He knows when I’m gonna pray to him about that thing. He planted it in my heart to desire that connection with him. so that I would pray, so that I would ask that question, so that he could move on my behalf. And so when he answers prayers for me It’s more than a oh I have a father who will listen to me. It’s no, I have a father who’s so good that he would plant those seeds of faith. Like it’s so much bigger for me And even in the bad, to recognize, like, well, I know the truth that this is a dark spot on a big painting that’s beautiful.

Mark:

Hmm.

Justin:

I don’t like it.

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

I don’t want to be in this black. And yet I know there’s purpose. And sometimes yeah, and this is not to say, uh I don’t struggle anymore because I know that there’s purpose. No, in fact, the struggle is different and I would say in some ways harder to say. I don’t want this. I don’t like this. I can’t escape it. Help. Like help me or help it? Like because And it is a desperate prayer that calls on his love and whatever. And at the same time recognizing that there’s a purpose.

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

And if he doesn’t answer There’s a purpose. If I die because of the situation, well, good. There’s a purpose and I don’t know if all that makes sense, but like Well

Mark:

it makes sense in the process of what we what we did because I think that’s the what you’re describing is that process of coming to the end of willpower.

Justin:

Or

Mark:

free will, that I can will it into existence, whereas there is a God who cares enough about me that he won’t necessarily let me build my own Tower of Babel, if you will. He won’t let me go that far to where he orchestrate circumstances to where I always have the option to come back towards him. And he’s And he’s make he’s he works that into my life in such a way that I can choose to continue to go my own way. And I can even separate myself from him, but it’s not that he’s ever unaware of where I’m at and still continuing to provide opportunity. in that wrestling for me to turn and be able to say, okay, God, yeah, this this whole life experience is bigger than me. And and I need your help. I need your help understanding. I need your help living. This is bigger than me. And I need your help with it. And I and I and I think you like you’re you’re saying, I think so often people get into that spot where there is a choice. to choose or yeah I’m I’m here again I’m thinking of Ernie you know again and it’s like this wrestling that I’m doing with I I I’m having a difficult time praying that God takes him Because it seems in that moment, yes, I I recognize he’s glowing to glory, I re recognize he’s going to heaven, and that’s best for him. But yet in my humanness, I have a difficult time saying, God, take somebody. Because that’s bigger than me. And yeah, so yeah, I wrest with give him healing. But then we hear, you know, so many people, well, I prayed for healing and God didn’t answer that prayer. So God doesn’t love, God doesn’t exist. You follow me? And I so right now in this moment I can understand both sides of that equation. And it I’m recognizing that It’s more complicated than than my small mind can comprehend.

Justin:

I think you’re oh just Yeah, I think when when life gets tough, well here I’ll I’ll say the inverse. Our theology is the strongest when we’re most comfortable. It’s like we get it all figured out and then we live in that figured outness like I know God this is what he does and this is how it works and I know you’re living this way because that’s what happened and this is And I know this is this because of that, and then BAM, we get smacked across the head with something with life.

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

And the things that were black and white. You got hit hard enough now. They now look purple.

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

Sure. Or whatever. You know what I’m saying? It shifts our perspective. It causes us to rethink and I believe and hope and desire that that will be true of me the rest of my life. I don’t want to ever figure it out because I know I don’t, but there are times I feel like I’ve got a pretty good lock on it.

Mark:

I know who God is. I know what he’s doing.

Justin:

Yeah.

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

Yeah. And then the like I said in those moments where it’s like, uh I very strongly believe in his sovereignty, predestination, all these things.

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

But then in those moments, it’s like Help?

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

Can you, will you?

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

Is that a thing you do? I don’t know. But yet you told me to pray. You said, give me the desires of my heart. Okay, I’m gonna believe what you said.

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

Right?

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

Despite knowing that you won’t listen to me because you’ve already predestined it or whatever. It’s like, no, no, no, no, no The Bible says this too.

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

You know what I’m saying? And so that theology becomes a little less black and fades a little more into that gray spot in the middle you’re talking about, which is healthy for me. You know, like can’t speak for everyone, but yeah. Um I also think too like yeah. Yeah.

Mark:

Go ahead.

Justin:

I this is I don’t know. I kind of took a left turn in my thoughts, but we hear definitions of God. We hear the uh like he’s called the line of the tribe of Judah, right?

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

And yet we know that he’s not a lion, right? We know he’s something much bigger than that.

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

And yet a lion is one representation

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

Of who he is. And it provides a view into who he is. And the Bible has how many names of God? It’s a lot. There’s a bunch. It’s a lot.

Mark:

Yeah, no doubt.

Justin:

And yet we don’t believe any single one of those as being the single name of God.

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

And therefore, this is how it is, because the Bible says it. Bam. Problem solved. He’s a lion. You know? It’s like, no, no, no. But also says he’s a lamb.

Mark:

Sure.

Justin:

He’s a lamb of God, you know?

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

At least Jesus is. He was the

Mark:

Jesus

Justin:

the lion as well, right?

Mark:

Yep.

Justin:

Um the point is we get so many facets into who he is in the word of God. God and free will is one of those facets that’s very a very clear-cut facet through the word of God. And so I think uh when you look at that facet, to believe that’s all it is, he’s a lion, that’s all it is, is I think missing the point. And then when you see the other facet of his sovereignty and he’s in control he knows exactly what’s going on he planned this from the beginning of time and you hear this and all this and that’s the facet Right?

Mark:

True.

Justin:

That my tendency was to shift from this facet of free will to this one. Like no free will, all predestination, God’s sovereignty. And yet, this facet didn’t go away. This name of God wasn’t removed from the Word of God.

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

Because I believed only in this name of God.

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

And so uh there’s that wrestling of saying, okay, there’s something to this. And again I think when we get to heaven we’re not gonna look at him and say, Oh, he is a lion. Well

Mark:

we

Justin:

were wrong all along, he was just a lion, you know. Um and vice versa, like get to heaven, I’m not gonna think, oh, it’s just free will up and down, all the way through, or vice versa. And um I think instead what’s gonna happen is we’re gonna Mind blown, you know.

Mark:

No doubt.

Justin:

Oh, it’s that plus that plus that plus plus that. And it’s none of it makes sense, but it all makes sense and

Mark:

my

Justin:

Even redeemed mind, whatever, you know, God transforms us in in when we get to heaven or whatever that looks like, even that version of me is still gonna be an image of him. And I’m still only gonna get a glimpse. But maybe for the rest of eternity, I get to just keep walking around in this knowledge and learning more and more just like I am now. But I’ll never be him, therefore I’ll never have it. I don’t know, it’s just so

Mark:

Yeah

Justin:

fascinating.

Mark:

Yeah. Cause I’m and uh I respect the fact that, you know, on one end of that continuum, as we talked about, you know, I’m a robot. I don’t have any choices. I’m automatic, you know, you know, and I And on the other end, it’s it’s all willpower.

Justin:

Yes.

Mark:

And I

Justin:

never send me back to that end, please.

Mark:

And I and I And I just think about them, you know, on those continuums.

Justin:

Yeah.

Mark:

And it’s like , I’m so thankful. That it’s not either or. But I get this opportunity to do both and.

Justin:

Yeah.

Mark:

And Will I will I wrestle with that part of me that aligns more with the robot at times? Or and will I wrestle with that part of me that wants to choose free, you know, have us this influence over God in a willpower, you know, type dynamic? But I think part of it is this ability to recognize that neither one is most beneficial. And it can be both and and there are will be circumstances that will challenge me where I’ll have to well or where I will need to learn. It’s it’s a it’s interesting because um This is I guess the the neat part for me is sometimes in in sessions I I operate by three C’s. Okay. And the the first C is uh creating a context for change. And that’s all about safety. In other words, a person isn’t necessarily going to change unless they feel safe And I think that’s the when I can recognize that God desires, is is loving and It I am safe with him even in the midst of my insecurities Even in the midst of the war, you know, raging around me, there’s still a safety. And I can work and I can I can wrestle because I think the the the um creating is when we’re like God. It’s it’s the it’s the it’s the working that I’m doing as I work through, you know what I’m saying? That that to create that space, to create opportunity for change. And for me, that’s critical because it’s about recognizing that I’m safe with God. And then I’m able to allow him to challenge my personal patterns and cycles. And that that C is about vulnerability and support. Because I’m not going to change unless I feel safe. But when I’m safe. With who God is, then I can be vulnerable and then I receive his support. And I can challenge these patterns and cycles in my life that say, no, it’s this way. It’s this way. It’s gotta be this way. And so I live in that cycle doing the same thing over and over again by my willpower And then, you know, but as I’m vulnerable, then I receive his support. And then that support allows me to be more vulnerable And it helps me even get to the point of the third C is consolidation where I’m learning. And learning is the ability to compile it all, consolidate, gather it together. In such a way that says, yeah, it’s okay to be vulnerable with God, and sometimes the safest place is being vulnerable with him in that moment when I don’t want to be vulnerable. And yet, unless I am, I don’t feel his support. If I’m trying to do it in my own strength, I don’t feel his support. I don’t feel that um compassion says yeah I’m here I gotcha I gotcha you know and I and that’s uh that’s what’s going through my mind as well I think about you know it’s like yeah He um what’s uh shucks? Um thinking of a movie Narnia the end where uh the little girls uh watching Aslan walk away And she’s there with Tumness, is it? Have you ever seen Oh and Yeah, and she talks about um Him God being good, but Tumnus says yeah, he’s good, but he’s not safe. You follow me? And I would challenge that to a certain degree. Yes, because he but It’s not always comfortable, and I think we under s I think we sometimes misconstrue safety with comfort. And I think that’s where comfort is sometimes counter to our growth. And therefore, we like comfort and we and that’s part of I I would even bring that back to having to relearn, you know, what is actually safe.

Justin:

Right. Right.

Mark:

You follow me?

Justin:

Yeah.

Mark:

Because because I can have I can I can have, as you were sharing, and I, you know, I can have this pornography habit that seems safe. I can go there and I can it can seem as if that individual, that image, offers me acceptance, which is safety. You follow me? But I but that’s unhealthy safety. And that’s where I have to come back and and and recognize I need to create a space for change and relearn what safety actually is.

Justin:

Yeah, because we equate safety. Safety with comfort.

Mark:

Yes.

Justin:

I think comfort is the trick, right?

Mark:

Yes.

Justin:

And and we have to relearn safety to understand that comfort does not always represent safety. In the case of, like you said, pornography, it’s comfort.

Mark:

Right.

Justin:

It’s comfortable. It’s easy, it’s whatever, but it’s not safe.

Mark:

Exactly.

Justin:

Yeah.

Mark:

Yeah.

Justin:

And sometimes growth is the safe. Safest and it feels the least safe.

Mark:

Yes, exactly. So yeah, and I and I think that’s where we can trust. Because I think t trust is what we’re actually looking at sometimes. Trust, trust versus safety, complacency or comfort. versus actual safety, and we can recognize that God is bigger, that there is purpose in it, even though it may feel uncomfortably unsafe at times as I’m relearning what it looks like to trust God and the fact that He does love and care for me right where I’m at.

Justin:

It’s good. I think of uh oh, we’re about out of time.

Mark:

Yeah. I

Justin:

think the recording will stop and 20 seconds.

Mark:

That’s true. So I think unless you want to wrap something up.

Justin:

Oh that’s good. That’s good. There’s way too much.

Mark:

So this is how we see it

Justin:

Hey, thank you for listening to our podcast. If you like how I see it, please do all the things that podcasts tell you to do. Subscribe, rate, review, follow us, uh, and or talk nicely about us on social media. If you want to reach out, the email is us at howiseeit.click. Yep, I said dot click. As in dot C-L-I -C-K Please tell your friends about this show, and we’ll see you on the next one.